4 guests · 1 Bedroom · 1 Bath






Book Now

(610) 755-8244Daytime (610) 955-5055Evening

Ask for Cape May Holly Suite between 6AM-11PM EST

The Holly Suite

Welcome to the Cape May Holly Suite

The Cape May Holly Suite is located on Jackson Street in the heart of Cape May's historic district at the Cape May Puffin Suites. The Cape May Holly Suite is a charming vacation rental that offers a cozy and comfortable stay in one of the country's most well-preserved Victorian seaside towns. The Holly Suite is a perfect destination for those seeking a unique and memorable vacation experience.

The Holly Suite is located just 1/2 block to the beach and steps to the Washington Street Mall restaurants and shops. The Cape May Holly Suite offers cozy outdoor spaces for guests to relax and unwind. Our private ocean view roof deck is the place to relax and enjoy a beverage, read a book, or just enjoy the view of the ocean and famous Congress Hall. The Puffin also features a large front porch with lots of comfortable seating. Enjoy our porch rockers and watch the horse carriages, trolleys and people walk down scenic Jackson Street. Jackson Street is gas lit at night to offer the perfect ambiance for sharing special times with friends and families. 

The Holly Suite is a one bedroom, one bath condominium that sleeps up to 4 guests comfortably with a queen size bed in the main bedroom and two full-size sleeper sofas. The sleeper sofas are located in the living room and the sitting room/sun room. The sitting room/sun room can be used as a second bedroom for additional privacy. Both sleeper sofas have upgraded mattresses

The interior of the Holly Suite features a blend of modern amenities and antique furnishings, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The Holly Suite features a kitchen, living room with plenty of seating and a sitting room/sunroom. Our newly renovated suite is roomy and bright, featuring central air, fireplace, plenty of comfortable seating and much more. The living room also has a 50-inch QLED smart TV for your enjoyment and TV in the bedroom. The suite is child friendly and smoke free.

One of the highlights of the Cape May Holly Suite is its prime location on Jackson Street, which is renowned for its beautiful Victorian homes and tree-lined streets. Guests can easily explore Cape May's historic district on foot, with the beach, shops, restaurants, and attractions just a short stroll away. The suite is also close to the Cape May Lighthouse, Cape May Point State Park, and the Cape May Bird Observatory, making it a perfect base for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers.

We provide free offsite parking for one vehicle at the Bank Street parking lot and four beach tags to be used during your vacation.

Location is everything when choosing a vacation destination. Jackson Street is the most historic and one of the first streets in Cape May. You will love how close the ‘Holly Suite at The Puffin’ is to everything. Our Guest come back year after year for one simple reason, it doesn't get any better for a Cape May vacation rental. 

Photo Gallery

What Our Guests Are Saying

  • Marvelous Stay

    Your place is elegant, charming and quite cozy. You have thought of everything. We love also how close it is to excellent restaurants (one right across the street!). We've had a marvelous stay. When t...read more.

    Donald of Santa Barbara, CA US
    Reviewed May 9, 2024

  • The Best Location!

    This was our 2nd time staying at the Holly Suite. The location cannot be topped. Jackson Street is just a short walk to the beach and the mall area. The front porch is wonderful to relax and view the ...read more.

    Chris of Brooklyn, NY US
    Reviewed Oct 3, 2023

  • Everything is Perfect

    The space clean and well-equipped. Communication with the owner is easy. The pictures are accurate and the location is perfect.

    Jason of Pittsburgh, PA US
    Reviewed Sep 6, 2023

  • Can't wait to come back!

    The BEST place to stay in Cape May. Location and amenities were perfect. So cozy and comfortable. Would recommend to anyone!

    Leela of ., PA US
    Reviewed Jul 15, 2023

  • Wonderful!

    We’re so glad we found this condo in Cape May. I don't think we could have found a better location. The beach and restaurants were so close. It made it super convenient with our child. The location an...read more.

    Janet of Scranton, PA US
    Reviewed May 20, 2023

  • Perfect location!

    We had a wonderful stay! My two kids loved sleeping in the sun room, and the apartment was clean and spacious for us. We loved the outdoor shower and having laundry on site was really helpful. Locatio...read more.

    Laura of New York, NY US
    Reviewed Sep 18, 2022

  • Great stay in Cape May

    The Holly Suite was a great place to stay! It was clean and the most perfect location. One block to the Washington mall and one block to the beach which was very important to us since we were travelin...read more.

    Dana of Spottswood, NJ US
    Reviewed Jul 19, 2022

  • Perfect place to stay in Cape May

    We were able to grab a last minute stay at the Holly Suite the end of June. Bonus!! This is a great place, clean, comfortable, nice decor and a sweet roof deck, with a gorgeous view of the ocean. ...read more.

    Pat of Duluth, MN US
    Reviewed Jul 2, 2022

  • Perfect

    We had a perfect time. This property is the absolute best way to get a full Cape May experience.

    Steven of Morristown, NJ, NJ US
    Reviewed Jun 10, 2022

  • 40th Anniversary

    Perfect space for two adults, very clean snd perfectly appointed. Such a great location, easy walking distance to all points of interest. We would love to visit again.

    Gail of Coatesville, PA US
    Reviewed May 16, 2022

The Latest From The Holly Suite

  • Vacation Rental Photo

    Summer in Cape May

    Cape May is the ideal destination for those seeking a quintessential summer experience. Cape May boasts some of the most beautiful beaches on the ...

  • Vacation Rental Photo

    Springtime in Cape May

    Springtime in Cape May is a delightful season that brings forth a kaleidoscope of colors, vibrant gardens, and an array of outdoor activities, all set ...

  • Vacation Rental Photo

    Visiting Beautiful Cape May

    Exploring the Rich History of Cape May: A Journey through New Jersey's Charming Seaside TownCape May, located on the southernmost tip of New Jerse ...

Amenities & Accommodations

Cape May Holly Suite is a newly renovated one-bedroom vacation rental that accommodates up to 4 guests. Tom and Alison are the proud owners, and we take great pride in providing our suite renters with a wonderful place to stay. Cape May Holly Suite features two private entrances, a fully equipped kitchen with granite counter tops, stove, oven, microwave, dishwasher, coffee maker, toaster, dishes, and silverware, etc. There is also a newly renovated bathroom with a tiled shower. The bedroom is unique in style offering a beautiful 1880s Victorian bedroom suite with peach walnut marble tops. You will love the bedroom it is very comfortable and cozy. 

The suite also features two full-size sleeper sofas with memory foam mattresses for extra comfort. The sitting room/ sunroom can be used as a second bedroom.  The room is private with a separate entrance off the kitchen.

The Holly Suite Cape May vacation rental offers a private roof deck with views of the ocean and historic Congress Hall. The suite has central air conditioning to keep you cool on those hot summer days.If vacationing in the off-season, the suite also has a beautiful electric fireplace for cool evenings.The suite also has two smart LED TVs with cable and high-speed internet.

Located in downtown historical district, we offer a 'two – seven-night' vacation rental on Jackson Street in Cape May. If you are looking for a beautiful one-bedroom unit that comfortably sleeps four with all the amenities of home, the Holly Suite at Cape May Puffin Suites is an excellent choice.

Vacation Rental Condo Amenities

    • Television
    • Air Conditioning
    • Central Heating
    • Full Kitchen
    • Washer & Dryer
    • Wireless Internet
    • Free Parking
    • Keyless Entry
    • Private Ocean-View Roof Deck
    • Victorian Bedroom Suite
    • Sunroom/ 2nd Bedroom with Sleeper Sofa
    • Close to Beach 1/2 Block
    • Electric Fireplace
    • Child Friendly
    • Close to restaurants and shops
    • Free Parking
    • NO Pets
    • Shared front porch veranda
    • Outdoor shower


Rate PeriodDailyWeekly
May 2024: May 1-May 31, 2024 (3 Night Minimum)$300-$335$2,170
June 2024: Jun 1-Jun 14, 2024 (4 Night Minimum)$345$2,415
Summer Season 2024: Jun 15-Aug 30, 2024 (7 Night Minimum)$395$2,765
August 31- September 20: Aug 31-Sep 20, 2024 (4 Night Minimum)$395$2,765
Fall Season: Sep 21-Oct 31, 2024 (3 Night Minimum)$325$2,275
November 2024: Nov 1-Nov 22, 2024 (2 Night Minimum)$245$1,715
Holiday Season: Nov 23-Dec 31, 2024 (3 Night Minimum)$325$2,275
Spring Season: Jan 1-Apr 30, 2025 (2 Night Minimum)$225$1,575
May 2025: May 1-May 31, 2025 (3 Night Minimum)$300-$335$2,170
June 2025: Jun 1-Jun 14, 2025 (4 Night Minimum)$345$2,415
Surcharges for holidays and special seasons may apply. All currencies are shown in USD.

During the Summer season, starting in June and ending in September, we require a 7-night minimum stay, Saturday - Saturday. During the off-Season, a 2- or 3-night minimum stay policy is offered. 

Please view the Booking and Availability calendar for availability.

There are NO Booking fees and NO New Jersey taxes when you reserve The Holly directly through our website.

Rental Policies and Conditions

Payments Accepted: Credit Cards, Personal Checks.

Credit cards are accepted (an additional non-refundable 3% service fee will be applied to total amount charged).

Cape May Holly Suite vacation rental does not allow smoking or pets. To keep our home beautiful for your enjoyment, a cleaning fee of $150.00 is charged per reservation. 

*Our complete Rental Agreement is viewable prior to finalizing a reservation on this website.

Please review our rental lease during the reservation process for complete details on our rental policies including occupancy limits and check-in times.


Cape May Holly Suite, 32 Jackson Street, Cape May, New Jersey 08204

The Holly Suite @ The Puffin is perfectly located half a block to the beach and half a block to the Washington Street pedestrian mall.  Within just a few blocks you can walk to the beach, the Convention Center, restaurant/bars with live music including fine dining, miniature-golf courses, and a large variety of shops and restaurants! Enjoy a short bike ride or scenic drive to visit the Cape May lighthouse, Sunset Beach, the WWII tower, Physick's Estate, Beach Plum Farm, wineries, and more. A short drive will also bring you to the Whale watching and Sunset cruises, fishing, Cape May Zoo, Wildwood Boardwalk, and movie theatres.

From Atlantic City, NJ (48 Miles)

Atlantic City Expressway to Garden State Parkway South.

From Philadelphia, PA (87 Miles)

Walt Whitman Bridge, Route 676 South, Route 55 South, Route 47 South to Garden State Parkway South.

From New York, NY (169 Miles)

Route 95 South (NJ Turnpike) to Garden State Parkway South.

From Washington, D.C. (186 Miles)

Route 95 North (NJ Turnpike), Route 40 East, Route 55 South, Route 47 South to Garden State Parkway South