Guest Reviews

Great Place & Location!

We stayed at The Puffin Atlantic Suite & it was great! The place was clean and exactly as described. Instructions were clear and detailed on what we needed to do. Communication was clear and quick if we needed anything! Location was perfect to the beach & shopping. I really like how they also offered a second parking spot a few blocks away. Would absolutely stay again.

- Kelsey of Quakertown, PA US
Reviewed Apr 11, 2024

December 2023 Stay

The Puffin Atlantic was a great place to stay, we were very pleased with everything about it. Walking distance to everything we enjoy at Cape May. The place was very clean and spacious. Parking was as simple as it gets. Kelly and Kevin were very responsive (email and text messages) and very accommodating. Definitely a 5 Star stay. Thank you.

- Brian of Warwick, NY US
Reviewed Dec 12, 2023

Comfortable and clean

Great location! Comfortable and clean place. Kelly was very responsive from emails to direct text messages. We would definitely recommend this stay.

- Brian of Warwick, NY US
Reviewed Dec 12, 2023

Fantastic roof deck and kitchen!

Great stay! Location location location!! Comfy and cozy! Fantastic roof deck and kitchen! Thank you so much!

- Meg of Carlisle, PA US
Reviewed Nov 20, 2023

Great Stay at the Puffin!

Our family had a fantastic stay in the Atlantic suite. The renovations are beautiful and it had everything we needed. Kelly was super helpful throughout our stay.

- Samantha of Boston, MA US
Reviewed Sep 22, 2023

Atlantic Suite - Perfect!

Neat. Clean. Well appointed. Beautiful kitchen. Perfect location. Easy walk to beach or shopping/restaurants. Awesome outdoor deck. Kelly and Kevin are terrific hosts. Been there twice and definitely will return.

- Frederick of Poughkeepsie, NY US
Reviewed Jul 17, 2023

Sunsets from the deck

My family and I celebrated our June birthdays while in beautiful Cape May. We felt right at home here and the location was great - walkable to beach, shops, and restaurants. We enjoyed watching the sunsets from the deck off of our unit. It was a great week!

- Lynn of Downington, PA US
Reviewed Jun 30, 2023

We would definitely stay here again

We had a great stay! It is in a perfect location - close to the beach, shopping, and great restaurants. The rooftop deck was a nice area for us to relax and see the beach. Kelly was great to communicate with offering us flexible check in / check out accommodations and answering quickly when we had questions about parking. We would definitely stay here again!

- Mollie of Somerville, NJ US
Reviewed Jun 26, 2023

Great stay at the Puffin

My family and I stayed at the Atlantic Suite at the Puffin for a week, and couldn't have been more happy. The rental was clean, well appointed, and above all, in the PERFECT location. We'll be coming back!

- Alex & Maria of Doylestown, PA US
Reviewed Jun 23, 2023

PERFECT location

We were in town for a few days for a family event and absolutely fell in love with Cape May! The Puffin is in the PERFECT location. Just steps to shopping, restaurants and the beach - it is so beautifully located to experience everything this charming town has to offer. The rooftop deck and wrap around porch were wonderful to spend time sitting and chatting and the accommodations were comfortable for our group.

- Michelle of Goshen, NY US
Reviewed Jun 10, 2023

Rooftop deck with a sea view

Beautiful, clean apartment in an amazing location. On-site parking. Kelly was really easy to communicate with and even offered us early check-in/late check-out. Rooftop deck with a sea view was the cherry on top! Would highly recommend staying here.

- Aoife of Medford Lakes, NJ US
Reviewed Jun 8, 2023

Loved the rooftop lounge

Kelly is very informative and constantly gives updates. The place was very clean, with a nice layout. Loved the rooftop lounge area, definitely will stay here again.

- Edward of Hanover Twp, PA US
Reviewed Dec 5, 2022

Just absolutely perfect!

The Puffin Atlantic Suite is perfectly appointed, comfortable, and very clean. The hosts proactively provide all the information you will need to enjoy your stay. The deck provides a gorgeous view of the shore and Congress Hall.

- Beth of Riverton, NJ US
Reviewed Nov 1, 2022

Great Weekend Escape

The Puffin Atlantic Suite was perfect for a mom's weekend getaway! Right in the heart of Cape May! We were steps away from everything Cape May has to offer... restaurants, shops, beach and so much more. And the few hours we wanted to relax, the outdoor 3rd floor deck was AMAZING! This Air B&B is perfect for a friends getaway, family vacation or anything in between.

- Lauren of Wall, NJ US
Reviewed Oct 27, 2022

Rooftop deck was a highlight!

Location was excellent…within walking distance to all the shops and restaurants. Roof top deck was a highlight! Unit was clean and kitchen had all the things we needed.

- Courtney of Middletown, NJ US
Reviewed Oct 10, 2022

Great roof deck

Great spot! Tons of Cape May charm, with an updated kitchen, great roof deck and super convenient location. Was able to stay very comfortably with three other adults. Don’t forget to pack your sheets!

- Matt of Brooklyn, NY US
Reviewed Oct 2, 2022

Unbeatable location in a Gorgeous Victorian

Can’t say enough great things about this condo! Steps from the beach (and a cute walk past gorgeous Victorians at that) and also steps from the cute Cape May downtown shops. Kelly made our stay at the Puffin so special—she was quick to communicate and very transparent. The condo was quaint, but the rooftop deck just for our unit was where we spent most of our time enjoying the ocean view.

- Catherine of Washington DC, DC US
Reviewed Sep 11, 2022

New Deck was amazing

The Atlantic Suite was super clean and comfortable. The updated kitchen, bedroom, and new deck were amazing! Amazing location too!! Our family really enjoyed our stay :)

- Ashley of Marlboro, NJ US
Reviewed Sep 4, 2022

We will be back!

We loved our stay at The Puffin Atlantic Suite! The location is key with convenience to everything. The suite is perfectly positioned on the third floor, proffering a quiet retreat leaving the din of the street behind after a day of being out. The new deck was my partner's and my favorite place to sit every evening, recapping our day. The two smaller bedrooms were perfect for my teenage sons to isolate themselves, while the suite was spacious for us all to share time together. Kelly is an attentive host and was a true pleasure to work with. Pay special attention to Kelly & Kevin's vehicle size recommendations for parking. It is tight—every inch matters in Cape May!

- Jennifer of Fort Collins, CO US
Reviewed Jul 25, 2022

I will definitely stay again!

Kelly’s place was amazing! It had the perfect location and the hosts were very communicative. The house was clean and had everything we need. I will definitely stay again!

- Lauren of Howell, NJ US
Reviewed Jun 26, 2022

Best location in all of Cape May

Jackson St is the place to be! Walking distance to everything and we loved the Puffin’s big porch, waving to the trolley tours, horse and buggies, and Tommy hotdogs, just to name a few! The house was perfect for our family of 4 and we loved our stay. The owners are kind and super responsive. We had 0 issues, and enjoyed every min in the best shore town of all of N.J.

- Gina of Lake Hopatcong, NJ US
Reviewed Jun 17, 2022

Clean, spacious and the location!

We had a wonderful stay at the Puffin over Thanksgiving. The suite was clean, spacious and the location couldn't be better! The hosts responded to messages promptly and were very accommodating

- Rae Ellen of Hoboken, NJ US
Reviewed Nov 27, 2021

Another great stay at the Puffin

We had another great stay at the Puffin! Kelly and Kevin are great hosts, and we thoroughly enjoyed our time at their place. Great location, very clean and easy check-in and check-out process.

- Richard of Pennington, NJ US
Reviewed Nov 15, 2021

Girls weekend at the Puffin Atlantic Suite

We had a lovely little get away at the Puffin inn! It was in the perfect location to everything and even though we didn’t have great beach weather there was plenty to do! We were never more then a 5 min walk to tons of restaurants! And the Mad Batter was directly across the street! Thank you for our lovely stay!

- Kristi of TBD, NJ US
Reviewed Oct 13, 2021

The Atlantic Suite was charming

The Atlantic Suite at the Puffin was wonderful and I would recommend to anyone visiting Cape May! Kelly and Kevin were outstanding hosts and extremely communicative leading up to and throughout the stay. The suite was charming, well appointed and the location could not be beat! Five Stars.

- Jill of Denver, CO US
Reviewed Oct 5, 2021

All around perfect spot

Very enjoyable stay - great location, great people, all around a perfect spot that is close to pretty much everything you must do or see in Cape May.

- Doug of Port Monmouth, NJ US
Reviewed Sep 27, 2021

The location can't be beat

We had a wonderful time staying at the Puffin Atlantic Suite. The location can't be beat; it's so convenient to the beach, and a stone's throw away from Washington Street Mall. Kelly was very communicative with providing information over to us along the way, and sent reminder emails as well. We definitely look forward to staying again, especially with an enhanced view of the ocean.

- Jerold of Parsippany, NJ US
Reviewed Sep 12, 2021

We cannot get over the location

Great location and a clean, spacious, comfortable flat. Owners are fantastic to deal with. It was a great time and we cannot get over the location. Hope to be back for a longer visit in the future.

- John of Schenectady, NY US
Reviewed Aug 18, 2021

Lovely place, great location!

Lovely place, great location. Lots of stairs, so if you're not into that, then just be aware... Looking forward to the winter 2021 renovation!!

- Nick of Downington, PA US
Reviewed Aug 14, 2021

Amazing trip -Great place!

Amazing trip in a great place! Super close to the beach and places to eat. Plenty of space for multiple couples.

- Katy of Centreville, VA US
Reviewed Jul 13, 2021

Best location in Cape May

We loved our time staying in the Atlantic suite at the Puffin. This is the best location in Cape May, with easy access to shops, restaurants, and the beach. Kelly was a fantastic host, responding quickly to questions and providing all the details we needed for easy check-in and a wonderful stay. The space is huge and made our family of 5 feel right at home. We only wished we could stay longer! Thanks so much, Kelly. We will definitely stay here again.

- Taunya of Irvine, CA US
Reviewed Jul 1, 2021

Location can't be beat!

Kelly was such a great host. Very responsive and truly made our trip a wonderful experience. The house was very clean and the location can’t be beat! Very very short walking distance to the beach and the towns shopping center.

- Brian of Bronx, NY US
Reviewed Jun 26, 2021

Porch was great

Everything was perfect! Tons of room for our family of four. The porch was great to sit and just enjoy outside!

- Michele of Tbd, NJ US
Reviewed May 29, 2021

Location was so convenient!

Our family of 6 adults had a great time staying in Cape May. The location was so convenient, we could walk to the beach, shopping, restaurant, and CVS.

- Sheryl of Ephrata, PA US
Reviewed May 28, 2021

The Puffin Atlantic Suite

We enjoyed the clean and comfortable accommodations at the Puffin Atlantic Suite. Our family of 6 adults was quite comfortable in the space, and especially enjoyed playing games in the living room and sitting on the porch downstairs. We were able to walk everywhere we wanted to go for several days, and enjoyed the close-by beach, restaurants, and shops.

- Sheryl of Ephrata, PA US
Reviewed May 26, 2021

Location was perfect!

Couldn’t ask for a better location, a block from the beach and a block from the mall. Porch was amazing!

- Jaime of Haddon Township, NJ US
Reviewed May 17, 2021

Puffin Atlantic Suite

Awesome location. Quick and responsive communication!

- Christy of Haddonfield, NJ US
Reviewed Apr 12, 2021

So close to EVERYTHING!

When people travel, location is usually a big deal. The Puffin is so close to EVERYTHING! You are a very short walk to the beach, shops and parking (which my friends and I needed). We had 7 people and the Puffin fit us all very comfortably. Kelly was an amazing host and made sure we were comfortable. I would absolutely recommend and I would love to stay at the Puffin again!

- Georgette of Oxford, PA US
Reviewed Apr 12, 2021

So much fun!!

The Puffin was the perfect spot for our first trip to Cape May. We were able to walk everywhere easily. The place was spotless and full of everything we needed to cook and entertain. The kids loved the bunk bed. We look forward to staying at the Puffin Atlantic again! Sincerely, Meenal Patil

- Meenal of Haddonfield, NJ US
Reviewed Apr 5, 2021

Great Spring Break Stay at The Puffin Atlantic Suite

The Atlantic Suite was the perfect location for our little Spring Break trip - and it was a much needed rest after a long winter indoors! The suite was the perfect size for our family of four, it was very clean, and the location can't be beat. We loved being able to walk half a block to both the beach and Washington Street Mall. Kelly was very responsive to any questions. We will definitely be back - thank you so much! Sherry, Vince, Ben, and Sarah

- Sherry of Middletown, MD US
Reviewed Mar 31, 2021

Great Apartment-Atlantic Suite

We loved the Puffin Atlantic Suite! Clean, comfortable and great location. Perfect for a fun getaway!

- Richard of Pennington, NJ US
Reviewed Mar 29, 2021

Great Stay!

We had a fantastic weekend at the Puffin, Atlantic Suite. It was the perfect spot for our family of 5 to celebrate a birthday weekend. The location of the home is perfect, we parked the car and never moved it!

- Heather of Manahawkin, NJ US
Reviewed Mar 22, 2021

Walkable to everything

Kelly’s place is a great location. Walkable to everything and such a cute place :)

- Lauren of King of Prussia, PA US
Reviewed Mar 15, 2021

Cozy and Comfortable

Excellent place and lovely hosts! It was cozy and comfortable for us and our four kids. We loved sitting at the table chit chatting and we all took turns people watching out the windows in the living room. It was just a sweet little walk to get to the beach. We ate at Mad Batters twice which is right across the street and a local hit restaurant. We went in the winter but hope to return for warmer weather too! Thank you Kelly!

- Rebekah of Bethany, CT US
Reviewed Feb 16, 2021

Our Women and Girls Fall Getaway

We all love staying at the Puffin Atlantic Suite for our annual Fall Getaway Weekend. For my daughters, granddaughters and myself, it is the perfect place for us to enjoy the beauty of Cape May. We love that we can walk shopping, to restaurants, to the beach. We also enjoy sitting on the beautiful porch. The Atlantic Suite is always very clean when we arrive and it provides a cozy place for us to enjoy our time together. We hope that we can continue to stay here for many Falls to come.

- Nicole of Wernersville, PA US
Reviewed Oct 25, 2020

Couldn’t have asked for a better location!

Couldn’t have asked for a better location. Within walking distance to so many things. Kelly was quick to answer any emails. Will definitely return.

- Kristen of Brick, NJ US
Reviewed Oct 12, 2020

Spacious and welcoming; great location!

The Atlantic Suite was spacious and welcoming. It is in a great location where we easily walked to restaurants, stores and the beach. The best part is the wraparound porch where we ate breakfast and coffee and enjoyed the beautiful weather!

- Marisa of Woodland Park, NJ US
Reviewed Oct 5, 2020

Super Clean!

Excellent location and super clean!

- Frank of Middlesex, NJ US
Reviewed Sep 21, 2020

This place was amazing!

This place was amazing! So close to everything great Cape May has to offer.

- Katie of Point Pleasant, NJ US
Reviewed Sep 15, 2020

Great walkable location

Great walkable location is convenient to everything. Kelly was a great host and we had very good communication before and during the trip. Seamless check-in and everything as described. Thank you!

- Erich of Philadelphia, PA US
Reviewed Sep 4, 2020

The Atlantic Suite Puffin

My family and I really enjoyed our stay at the house. There was plenty of space for all of us to spread out and we were very comfortable there. Great place, great location, very clean , close to the beach and restaurants. Will be back again.

- Alfred of Bronx, NY US
Reviewed Aug 9, 2020

Perfect place for my family

The Puffin Atlantic Suite was a perfect place for my family of 5, ideally located steps away from the beach, restaurants and shopping. The owners were very responsive to our questions prior to our stay, and communicated all necessary details to us about check-in, the details of the apartment, and check-out. We appreciated and used the beach tags and off-site parking permit for a second car. The condo itself was spacious, clean, well decorated, and had an ample kitchen and living space for the 5 of us. We wholeheartedly recommend the Puffin, and hope to stay there again ourselves.

- Joe of Montclair, NJ US
Reviewed Aug 1, 2020

Atlantic Suite

We loved our stay! Clean. Neat. Plenty of room. Perfect location. Fully equipped kitchen. AC was great with ceiling fans helping. Will return to the Puffin again!

- Frederick of Poughkeepsie, NY US
Reviewed Jul 27, 2020

The Puffin Atlantic Suite - An Excellent Choice!

We had a wonderful stay in Cape May at The Puffin Atlantic Suite. The location was key to what made it so wonderful; the beach was 1/2 block to the right and the mall was 1/2 block to the left. Everything is just beyond your doorstep! It was perfect! Beautiful homes on this tree-lined street with a nice vibe of activity to watch from the large front porch while drinking coffee in the morning and sipping wine at night. The suite itself was very clean and nice. Air conditioning worked well. We were pleasantly surprised by the ocean view from the kitchen and master bedroom across the Congress Hall lawn! Parking was a plus; garage space provided. Outdoor shower, clothing line and space to store our beach gear made it easy to come and go to the beach. Owners were very responsive!

- Laura of Paoli, PA US
Reviewed Jul 19, 2020

Location was perfect!

Location was perfect. Easy to get questions answered. Porch was a great spot to hang out and relax and talk to other house guests.

- Joanna of Lebanon, PA US
Reviewed Jun 29, 2020

Beautiful and cozy front porch!

Great location! Very clean. Because it’s an old house, be prepared to walk and carry your items up narrow stairs to the top floor. Beautiful and cozy front porch to sit and enjoy a quiet cup of coffee in the morning! Host was kind enough to send check-in and check-out reminders. We had a great stay at the Puffin Atlantic Suite in Cape May!

- Molly of Pennsylvania, PA US
Reviewed Jun 25, 2020

A Dream Come True

“Beautiful Victorian home. Great space for a group of people/family. We spent a wonderful night on the front porch taking in the Cape May evening...a dream come true. Highly recommend.”

- Anthony of Wilmington, DE US
Reviewed Jun 23, 2020

The Puffin - Great Location

The location of the Puffin Suites is perfect, 1/2 block walk to beach, 1/2 block walk to Washington Mall shopping and lots of Cape May fun places. Loved being able to relax and enjoy a beverage on the front porch. Kelly & Kevin were great hosts and very responsive to any request!

- Corinne of Campbell Hall, NY US
Reviewed Sep 8, 2019

Fabulous location with wonderful porch

“Fabulous location with wonderful porch. You can't beat this for a few day stay in Cape May!”

- Jennifer of McLean, VA US
Reviewed Sep 6, 2019

Location, Location, Location!

Location, location, location!! Doesn't get any better than this. The front porch sitting, ease to the beach and dining make the Puffin a great place to stay. The updated bathrooms are top quality and having a kitchen with plenty of items made our stay 100% enjoyable! Kelly was quick with responses to any question I had. Thanks for a great vacation!

- Christina of McLean, VA US
Reviewed Sep 6, 2019

Very nice stay!

Absolutely wonderful location, on a beautiful historical block. We had a wonderful time. Kelly was very accommodating and quick to answer all questions. We will most definitely be returning !

- Diana of Paramus, NJ US
Reviewed Aug 16, 2019

Atlantic Suite

We had an wonderful week in Cape May! The Atlantic Suite had plenty of room for our family and we were in a perfect location! This is a perfect place to stay and enjoy all that Cape May has to offer.

- Melanie of Newton, NJ US
Reviewed Aug 6, 2019

Perfect getaway weekend!

The Puffin Atlantic Suite was absolutely perfect for my girls getaway weekend at the end of June. There was plenty of space for everyone (there were 6 of us) and we absolutely loved relaxing on the porch in the evenings. The house is less than a 5 minute walk to the beach in one direction, with shops and restaurants in the other direction. It was really nice that the rental came with beach tags which was a nice added touched. The off street parking was a huge help as well. Kelly and Kevin were incredibly responsive and made everything effortless. We could not have asked for a better stay! I hope to be back soon! Thanks for everything :)

- Ashley of Hoboken, NJ US
Reviewed Jul 8, 2019

Another Great Stay

This was our second stay at the Atlantic Suite, and we had a fantastic weekend. We reserved through the Puffin's online booking system, and the owners provided excellent communication from our initial reservation through the end of our visit. Our group of 5 (3 adults & 2 children) had plenty of room in the Atlantic Suite. Having both a powder room and full bath is very handy. The suite was clean and well-maintained, and it provided all the amenities we needed. The location is fantastic--a very short walk to the beach and shopping. It is a perfect place to stay. The onsite garage parking is very convenient. (We recommend backing in from the street if possible, as it was a little tricky backing out of the garage with our mini-van.) We definitely plan to return to the Atlantic Suite.

- Michelle of Schnecksville, PA US
Reviewed Jun 16, 2019