Vacation Rental Beach House in Cape May, NJ

8 guests · 3 Bedrooms · 1½ Baths






The Puffin Atlantic Suite

The Atlantic Suite at the Puffin is a year-round, 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath vacation condo perfectly located just 1/2 block to the beach and 1/2 block to the Washington Street pedestrian mall. This third floor penthouse offers views of historic Jackson Street from the front windows, and views of the ocean out over the famous Congress Hall lawn from the private rooftop deck and rear windows. Park your car on-site and enjoy everything Cape May has to offer at this well appointed home away from home.  

Photo Gallery

What Our Guests Are Saying

  • Great location and lots to do

    Great location, lots to do. The beach is right down the street. Loved the rooftop seating and porch.

    Sandra of Greenwich, CT US
    Reviewed Jun 29, 2024

  • Would stay again!

    We enjoyed our stay and would stay there again!

    Joel of Tbd, TX US
    Reviewed Jun 23, 2024

  • Highly Recommend!

    Incredibly proactive communication from the hosts. Amazing location, nearby everything in Cape May, and very walkable. Had a wonderful stay and would highly recommend!

    Filip of Philadelphia, PA US
    Reviewed May 21, 2024

  • Great Place & Location!

    We stayed at The Puffin Atlantic Suite & it was great! The place was clean and exactly as described. Instructions were clear and detailed on what we needed to do. Communication was clear and quick if more.

    Kelsey of Quakertown, PA US
    Reviewed Apr 11, 2024

  • December 2023 Stay

    The Puffin Atlantic was a great place to stay, we were very pleased with everything about it. Walking distance to everything we enjoy at Cape May. The place was very clean and spacious. Parking more.

    Brian of Warwick, NY US
    Reviewed Dec 12, 2023

  • Comfortable and clean

    Great location! Comfortable and clean place. Kelly was very responsive from emails to direct text messages. We would definitely recommend this stay.

    Brian of Warwick, NY US
    Reviewed Dec 12, 2023

  • Fantastic roof deck and kitchen!

    Great stay! Location location location!! Comfy and cozy! Fantastic roof deck and kitchen! Thank you so much!

    Meg of Carlisle, PA US
    Reviewed Nov 20, 2023

  • Great Stay at the Puffin!

    Our family had a fantastic stay in the Atlantic suite. The renovations are beautiful and it had everything we needed. Kelly was super helpful throughout our stay.

    Samantha of Boston, MA US
    Reviewed Sep 22, 2023

  • Atlantic Suite - Perfect!

    Neat. Clean. Well appointed. Beautiful kitchen. Perfect location. Easy walk to beach or shopping/restaurants. Awesome outdoor deck. Kelly and Kevin are terrific hosts. Been there twice and definitely more.

    Frederick of Poughkeepsie, NY US
    Reviewed Jul 17, 2023

  • Sunsets from the deck

    My family and I celebrated our June birthdays while in beautiful Cape May. We felt right at home here and the location was great - walkable to beach, shops, and restaurants. We enjoyed watching the more.

    Lynn of Downington, PA US
    Reviewed Jun 30, 2023

The Latest From The Puffin Atlantic Suite

Amenities & Accommodations

The Puffin Suites are perfectly located on Jackson Street in the heart of Cape May's historic district.  Relax with a coffee or drink while chatting and people watching from the large, covered front porch which looks out onto Jackson Street and is graced with beautiful neighboring historic homes. Enjoy the Victorian atmosphere of the Puffin lobby before heading upstairs to your sunny, spacious, quiet, third floor Suite. 

New since 2022: Private, ocean-view rooftop deck, wall of windows with ocean views, brand new eat-in kitchen with full-size appliances and granite counters, updated powder room and more!

The Atlantic Suite occupies the entire third floor of the Puffin and offers everything you need to make your stay comfortable in your home away from home in Cape May. Our cozy living room with vaulted ceilings has windows overlooking historic Jackson Street, a flat screen TV, DVD player, games, puzzles and books for relaxing. Free Wi-Fi and cable TV are also provided at the Atlantic Suite. The brand new kitchen is equipped with everything you need to prepare a full meal, or just make coffee or a snack to bring to the beach, to your private deck, or to enjoy on the front porch. A full wall of windows provides views of the beach over the famous Congress Hall lawn. Three bedrooms provide room for up to 8 guests. The large master bedroom has a Queen-size bed, Flat screen TV, views of the ocean and access to the private rooftop deck. Two additional small bedrooms provide privacy and sleeping area for 5 more guests - one bedroom has a Full-size bed, while the other bedroom has bunk beds with a Twin bed on top, and a Full-size bed on the bottom.  The living room also offers more sleeping options via a full size futon as well as a pull-out chair sleeper (suitable for a child).The updated bathrooms include a large bathroom with a full size tub and shower, and a brand new powder room with toilet and sink. 

You will be cool and comfortable in the summer with the new central air conditioning, as well as ceiling fans in most of the rooms. If the weather gets chilly, the HVAC unit will provide heat as well. On-site parking for one small to mid-size size car is reserved for your stay in the garage, and provides room for you to store other gear as well. Parking for a large or additional vehicle is also provided via permit at a nearby parking lot. Additional storage for boogie boards, beach chairs, sand buckets, etc is available in a covered area at the rear of the house. Laundry is also available on the ground level for guests of the Puffin Suites. An outdoor shower and clothes line help ease your transition from a hot, sandy day at the beach to a relaxing evening in your suite and around town. Keyless entry means you won't ever have to worry about losing the keys at the beach. 

Park your car and walk everywhere - the Puffin is conveniently located in the heart of the historic district with the beach, mini-golf, arcades, excellent shopping, restaurants, clubs and theatres just steps away!   

Vacation Rental Beach House Amenities

    • Television
    • Garage Access
    • Air Conditioning
    • Central Heating
    • Full Kitchen
    • Washer & Dryer
    • Wireless Internet
    • Free Parking
    • Keyless Entry
    • Balcony
    • Private ocean-view rooftop deck
    • Shared laundry on ground floor
    • DVD player
    • Selection of DVDs/games/puzzles/books
    • Dedicated parking spot in the garage
    • Additional permit parking at nearby lot
    • Dishwasher


Rate PeriodDailyWeekly
Summer Pricing late June-early Sept: Jun 22-Sep 7, 2024 (7 Night Minimum)$600$4,000
Puffin early Fall rates: Sep 8-Oct 31, 2024 (2 Night Minimum)$488$3,255
Puffin Fall - November: Nov 1-Nov 30, 2024 (2 Night Minimum)$409$2,730
Puffin - December: Dec 1-Dec 5, 2024 (2 Night Minimum)$378$2,520
Puffin - December: Dec 6-Dec 8, 2024 (2 Night Minimum)$385$2,567
Puffin - December: Dec 9-Dec 19, 2024 (2 Night Minimum)$378$2,520
Puffin - December: Dec 20, 2024-Jan 1, 2025 (2 Night Minimum)$470$3,133
Winter pricing January-March: Jan 2-Mar 31, 2025 (2 Night Minimum)$330$2,200
Spring pricing April-before Memorial Day: Apr 1-May 22, 2025 (2 Night Minimum)$475$3,165
Early Summer pricing: May 23-Jun 21, 2025 (2 Night Minimum)$578$3,850
Summer Pricing late June-early Sept: Jun 22-Sep 6, 2025 (7 Night Minimum)$630$4,200
Surcharges for holidays and special seasons may apply. All currencies are shown in USD.

Click on Rates and Special Offers to see any current coupons!!

Rental Policies and Conditions

Payments Accepted: Credit Cards, Online Checks, Personal Checks, Certified Checks.

There are NO Booking fees and NO New Jersey taxes when you reserve The Atlantic Suite directly through our website.

Credit cards are accepted (an additional non-refundable 3% service fee will be applied to total amount charged).

This is a pet-free (to guests) and non-smoking home (inside and out). To keep our home beautiful for your enjoyment, a cleaning fee of $150 is charged per reservation. 

A refundable security deposit of $300 is also collected with each rental.

As is the case with most NJ shore rentals, we provide pillows, blankets, quilts, and mattress pads, but you must provide your own linens (sheets and towels). See website for linen rental options.

We are a family-friendly vacation rental. We expect our guests to maintain the peaceful, relaxing atmosphere of The Puffin for all to enjoy.

Cancellation policy: Cancellations at least 90 days before arrival are fully refundable. Cancellations at least 60 days before arrival are refunded 50%. Cancellations less than 60 days from arrival are non-refundable.


The Puffin Suites are perfectly located half a block to the beach and half a block to the popular Washington Street pedestrian mall.  Within just a few blocks you can walk to the beach, the Convention Center, two theatres plus a dinner theatre, three mini-golf courses, and a large variety of shops and restaurants! Enjoy a short bike ride or scenic drive to visit the Cape May lighthouse, Sunset Beach, the WWII tower, Emlen Physick's Estate, Beach Plum Farm, wineries, and more. A short drive will also bring you to the Cape May Zoo, Wildwood Boardwalk, and movie theatres.